The Investment Framework Criminal Defense Firms Use to Evaluate SEO Pricing

SEO pricing is not arbitrary. Every quote you receive reflects someone's estimate of the labor, tools, and time required to move your firm up in a specific market against specific competitors. Understanding what drives cost helps you evaluate whether a proposal is scoped correctly — not just whether it fits your budget.

Market Competition

Criminal defense is one of the most competitive legal verticals in search. In large metros — Los Angeles, Miami, Houston, Chicago — you are competing against firms that have invested in SEO for years and hold strong domain authority. Catching up requires more content, more link acquisition, and more time. That scope is reflected in cost.

Smaller metros and mid-size cities have fewer entrenched competitors. In those markets, a well-executed local SEO program can move rankings meaningfully in 3–6 months with a more modest monthly investment.

Scope of Services

Not all SEO retainers cover the same work. A local-only package focused on Google Business Profile optimization, citation cleanup, and review strategy costs less than a full-funnel program that includes technical audits, practice-area content, link building, and authority development. Both are legitimate — they serve different firm situations.

Firm Size and Geographic Footprint

A solo practitioner serving one county needs different SEO than a multi-attorney firm with offices in four cities. Multi-location SEO requires separate GBP profiles, location-specific landing pages, and jurisdiction-targeted content — all of which add scope and cost. Single-location firms can often start smaller and scale up.

Starting Authority

If your website is technically broken, has thin or duplicate content, and has never earned a meaningful backlink, the early months of engagement involve remediation before growth. Firms starting from a stronger baseline often see faster initial movement, which affects how budget gets allocated in months one through four.

The following ranges are based on what we observe in the market and across engagements we have run for criminal defense firms. Actual scope varies by agency, deliverables, and contract terms. Use these as a framework for evaluation, not a fixed price list.

$300–$800/Month: Commodity Tier

At this budget, most agencies are delivering automated reports, basic citation submissions, and templated content. In our experience, this level of investment rarely produces meaningful Map Pack movement in criminal defense markets. The labor cost alone for competent SEO work exceeds this range. Treat sub-$800 proposals with skepticism unless the agency is explicitly scoping a very narrow, single-task engagement.

$1,500–$3,000/Month: Local SEO Foundation

This range funds a legitimate local SEO program: GBP optimization, citation building and cleanup, review strategy, basic on-page optimization, and monthly reporting. For firms in smaller markets or those starting with a reasonable website foundation, this scope can produce Map Pack visibility within 4–6 months. It typically does not include substantive link building or new content creation at volume.

$3,000–$5,000/Month: Full Local + Content Program

At this level, expect local SEO plus ongoing content production (practice-area pages, FAQs, blog posts targeting informational queries), technical optimization, and some link acquisition. This is the most common tier for mid-size criminal defense firms in competitive markets. Results in the 4–8 month window are realistic for organic rankings; Map Pack timelines vary by market.

$5,000–$8,000+/Month: Authority-Building Program

For firms in high-competition metros or those targeting statewide reach, this scope funds aggressive content production, proactive digital PR, citation authority across legal directories (Avvo, Justia, FindLaw, NOLO), and substantive link building. This is not a starting point for most firms — it is appropriate when local SEO is already established and organic growth is the primary acquisition channel.

One-Time Engagements

Technical SEO audits typically run $750–$2,500 depending on site complexity. These are appropriate before signing a retainer or after a traffic drop. Some firms also commission one-time content packages or link audits as standalone projects.

SEO is not an expense line — it is a client acquisition channel. The question is not whether $3,000/month feels expensive. The question is: what is one retained criminal defense client worth to your firm, and how many cases per year would SEO need to generate to justify the investment?

Case Value as the Anchor

Criminal defense case values vary widely by matter type. DUI and misdemeanor defense typically runs $3,000–$10,000 in attorney fees. Felony defense often starts at $5,000 and can reach $25,000 or more for complex matters. Federal defense retainers run higher still. These are general ranges — your firm's actual fee structure will differ.

If your average retained case is worth $6,000 in revenue and SEO generates two additional retained clients per month, the channel is producing $12,000/month against a $3,000–$4,000 investment. That math works. The variables are how long it takes to reach that volume and what conversion rate your intake process achieves on inbound leads.

Realistic Time to how to evaluate [ROI](/resources/attorney/attorney-seo-roi) before you how to evaluate ROI before you [sign a contract](/resources/attorney/hire-attorney-seo-agency).

Most criminal defense SEO programs take 4–6 months to produce measurable ranking movement and 6–9 months before inbound lead volume becomes consistent. This is not unique to criminal defense — it reflects how Google indexes, evaluates, and rewards content authority over time. Firms that expect ROI in month two will be disappointed regardless of the agency they hire.

The ROI calculation also depends on your intake process. Organic search traffic converts into retained clients only if your website, phone answering, and consultation process are functioning. SEO generates the inquiry — your firm closes it.

What to Track

Before starting any SEO engagement, establish baseline metrics: current organic traffic, Map Pack visibility for your top 10 target keywords, and monthly inbound inquiry volume by source. Without a baseline, you cannot measure movement — and you cannot hold an agency accountable for results.

How an SEO agreement is structured matters as much as the monthly price. Here is what to evaluate before signing.

Month-to-Month vs. Annual Contracts

Month-to-month contracts give you flexibility to exit if results do not materialize. They typically cost 10–20% more per month than equivalent annual agreements because the agency is absorbing more risk. For firms new to SEO or evaluating a new agency, month-to-month for the first 3–6 months is a reasonable ask.

Annual agreements often include better pricing and signal that an agency is planning a multi-phase program rather than short-term tactics. Signing an annual contract is reasonable if the agency provides a clear 12-month roadmap with milestones and defines what constitutes adequate progress.

Ownership of Assets

Confirm in writing that you own your website content, Google Business Profile, analytics accounts, and any backlinks acquired on your behalf. Some agencies retain access to these assets as a means of lock-in. This is a red flag regardless of the pricing offered.

Reporting and Accountability

A legitimate SEO agency provides monthly reports showing keyword ranking movement, organic traffic trends, GBP insights, and lead attribution where possible. Vague reporting — traffic is up, impressions improved — without showing movement on the specific keywords your firm cares about is insufficient. Define reporting expectations before signing.

Scope Creep and Add-Ons

Some agencies quote a low retainer and then bill separately for content, link building, or additional locations. Ask for an all-in monthly cost that covers the full scope of work you discussed. Understand what is excluded and what would trigger additional fees before you agree to terms.

These are the questions we hear most often from criminal defense attorneys evaluating whether to invest in SEO.

"I Already Run Google Ads — Why Do I Need SEO?"

PPC and organic SEO serve the same query pool but behave differently. Paid ads stop the moment you stop paying. Organic rankings, once established, continue generating traffic without a per-click cost. Many defense firms run both channels — ads for immediate volume, SEO for long-term cost efficiency. The two are not mutually exclusive, but they are not interchangeable either.

"My Practice Relies on Referrals — Will SEO Even Help?"

Referral-driven firms still benefit from SEO for two reasons. First, referred prospects almost always search your name before calling — a weak online presence loses clients your referral network already sent you. Second, SEO captures net-new clients who have no existing referral relationship, expanding your addressable market. Most successful defense firms treat referrals and search as complementary, not competing, channels.

"I Tried SEO Before and It Didn't Work"

This is worth unpacking. In our experience, when SEO has not worked for a law firm, the cause is usually one of three things: insufficient budget for the market's competition level, a short time horizon that did not allow rankings to develop, or an agency that delivered activity rather than strategy. Understanding which failure mode applies to your prior experience helps you evaluate whether a new engagement would be different.

"How Do I Know I'm Not Overpaying?"

Get two or three proposals. Ask each agency to specify, in writing, what deliverables are included monthly, what the agency's target keyword list is for your market, and what KPIs define success at 6 and 12 months. Price comparison without scope comparison is meaningless — a $2,000/month agency doing comprehensive local SEO may outperform a $4,000/month agency running generic content and vanity reports.